The findings have resurfaced the centuries-old conversation on coffee's health effects.
One study surveyed
more than 520,000 people in 10 European countries, making it the
largest study to date on coffee and mortality, and found that drinking
more coffee could significantly lower a person's risk of mortality.
The second study was
more novel, as it focused on nonwhite populations. After surveying over
185,000 African-Americans, Native Americans, Hawaiians,
Japanese-Americans, Latinos and whites, the researchers found that
coffee increases longevity across various races.
People
who drank two to four cups a day had an 18% lower risk of death
compared with people who did not drink coffee, according to the study.
These findings are consistent with previous studies
that had looked at majority white populations, said Veronica Wendy
Setiawan, associate professor of preventative medicine at USC's Keck
School of Medicine, who led the study on nonwhite populations.
"Given
these very diverse populations, all these people have different
lifestyles. They have very different dietary habits and different
susceptibilities -- and we still find similar patterns," Setiawan said.
The
new study shows that there is a stronger biological possibility for the
relationship between coffee and longevity and found that mortality was
inversely related to coffee consumption for heart disease, cancer,
respiratory disease, stroke, diabetes and kidney disease.
The
study on European countries revealed an inverse association between
coffee and liver disease, suicide in men, cancer in women, digestive
diseases and circulatory diseases. Those who drank three or more cups a
day had a lower risk for all-cause death than people who did not drink
coffee.
Both studies were published in the Annals of Internal Medicine.
"We
looked at multiple countries across Europe, where the way the
population drinks coffee and prepares coffee is quite different," said
Marc Gunter, reader in cancer epidemiology and prevention at Imperial
College's School of Public Health in the UK, who co-authored the
European study.
"The fact
that we saw the same relationships in different countries is kind of
the implication that its something about coffee rather than its
something about the way that coffee is prepared or the way it's drunk,"
he said.
The biological benefits -- and caveats
Coffee
is a complex mixture of compounds, some of which have been revealed in
laboratories to have biological effects, Gunter said.
Studies have shown that certain compounds have neuroprotective and anti-inflammatory properties that can help reduce risk for illnesses like Parkinson's disease.
In
the European study, people who were drinking coffee tended to have
lower levels of inflammation, healthier lipid profiles and better
glucose control compared with those who weren't. It is still unclear
which particular compounds provide health benefits, but Gunter said he
would be interested in exploring this further.
Both
studies separated smokers from nonsmokers, since smoking is known to
reduce lifespan and is linked to various deceases. However, they found
that coffee had inverse effects on mortality for smokers too.
"Smoking
doesn't seem to blunt the effects of coffee," Gunter said. "It didn't
matter whether you smoked or not. There was still a potential beneficial
affect of coffee on mortality."
However,
Dr. Alberto Ascherio, professor of Epidemiology and Nutrition at
Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, said people should be wary of
this finding.
"Even if
it was in some way true, it doesn't make sense to me, because by
smoking, you increase your mortality several-fold. Then, if you reduce
it by 10% drinking coffee, give me a break," said Ascherio, who was not
involved in the study.
"I
think it's a dangerous proposition because it suggests that a smoker
can counteract the effects of smoking by drinking coffee, which is
borderline insane."
The
studies complement work that has been done on coffee and mortality, he
said, and it has been reasonably documented that coffee drinkers have a
lower risk of death.
With
all observations from previous studies, however, it's difficult to
exclude the possibility that coffee drinkers are just healthier to begin
with, Gunter said.
People
who avoid coffee, particularly in places like the US and Europe where
drinking the beverage is very common, may do so because they have health
problems. Their higher mortality rate could be a result of them being
less healthy to begin with.
Join the conversation
"I
think that the solid conclusion is that if you're a coffee drinker,
keep drinking your coffee and be happy," Ascherio said. And if you're
not? "I think you can go on drinking your tea or water without a
problem."
Meanwhile, Gunter and Setiawan stand a bit more firmly on coffee as a health benefit.
"The
takeaway message would be that drinking a couple cups of coffee a day
doesn't do you any harm, and actually, it might be doing you some good,"
he said.
"Moderate coffee
consumption can be incorporated into a healthy diet and lifestyle,"
Setiawan said. "This studies and the previous studies suggest that for a
majority of people, there's no long term harm from drinking coffee."
No comments:
Post a Comment